As it has been verified that there will be no veto session, the Louisiana Legislature Log presents its 2026 Louisiana Legislature scorecard. Fourteen bills were selected and weighed for computation. These were chosen from the watch list compiled throughout the session. For a bill’s vote to be selected, in one chamber there had to be more than one legislator not voting for the winning or losing side.
Being that passage of bills depends upon the seated membership of a body, not voting is counted as a negative vote. However, if a legislator had a leave of absence granted for that day, his absent votes weren’t counted for bills voted on that day and the score adjusted to take that into account. In the case of constitutional amendments, the governor’s score would be adjusted similarly, although none featured in this year’s scorecard.
Here are the bills on which the scorecard was computed:
HB 181 – would reduce welfare fraud.
HB 294 – would decrease violence and disruption in places of worship.*
HB 578 – would correct and clarify state laws that indicate sex-based differences.
HB 691 – would increase election integrity.
HB 1137 – would protect employees from arbitrary adverse employment actions.
SB 194 – would prevent enrollment into Medicaid of nonqualifying noncitizens.*
SB 197 – would begin to reduce excess judicial positions.*
SB 207 – would remove the statute of limitations for official corruption.*
SB 217 – would begin to reduce excess judicial positions.*
SB 307 – would authorize the educational display of the Ten Commandments as a historical document and monument.
SB 312 – would create better transparency concerning professional dues in schools.
SB 425 – would expand options to remove from office misbehaving public officers.*
SB 479 – would increase accountability of public officials*
SB 157 – would create taxpayer-funded parental leave for school employees.*
Bills indicated with an asterisk (*) counted for 5 percent of the total score, while all others weighed in at 10 percent. In all instances but SB 157 the conservative/reform vote is in favor and the liberal/populist vote is against, where with SB 157 the conservative/reform vote is against and the liberal/populist vote is in favor.
Here are the House scores:
|
Amedee |
100 |
Republican |
|
Beaullieu |
100 |
Republican |
|
Carlson |
100 |
Republican |
|
Deshotel |
100 |
Republican |
|
Henry,
C |
100 |
Republican |
|
McCormick |
100 |
Republican |
|
Schamerhorn |
100 |
Republican |
|
Bacala |
95 |
Republican |
|
Bamburg |
95 |
Republican |
|
Berault |
95 |
Republican |
|
Billings |
95 |
Republican |
|
Borriaque |
95 |
Republican |
|
Broussard |
95 |
Republican |
|
Butler |
95 |
Republican |
|
Carrier |
95 |
Republican |
|
Carver |
95 |
Republican |
|
Chenevert |
95 |
Republican |
|
Coates |
95 |
Republican |
|
Dewitt |
95 |
Republican |
|
Dickerson |
95 |
Republican |
|
Egan |
95 |
Republican |
|
Farnum |
95 |
Republican |
|
Firment |
95 |
Republican |
|
Fontenot |
95 |
Republican |
|
Gadberry |
95 |
Republican |
|
Hebert |
95 |
Republican |
|
Horton |
95 |
Republican |
|
Kerner |
95 |
Republican |
|
Mack |
95 |
Republican |
|
McMahen |
95 |
Republican |
|
Melerine |
95 |
Republican |
|
Riser |
95 |
Republican |
|
Sawyer |
95 |
Republican |
|
Thomas |
95 |
Republican |
|
Turner |
95 |
Republican |
|
Ventrella |
95 |
Republican |
|
Villio |
95 |
Republican |
|
Wilder |
95 |
Republican |
|
Wright |
95 |
Republican |
|
Wyble |
95 |
Republican |
|
Landry,
J |
95 |
Republican |
|
Echols |
94 |
Republican |
|
McMakin |
94 |
Republican |
|
Spell |
94 |
Republican |
|
Boudreaux,
D |
90 |
Republican |
|
Boyer |
90 |
Republican |
|
Illg |
90 |
Republican |
|
McFarland |
90 |
Republican |
|
Muscarello |
90 |
Republican |
|
Orgeron |
90 |
Republican |
|
Owen,
C |
90 |
Republican |
|
St.
Blanc |
90 |
Republican |
|
Crews |
85 |
Republican |
|
Domangue |
85 |
Republican |
|
Edmonston |
85 |
Republican |
|
Galle' |
85 |
Republican |
|
Johnson,
M |
85 |
Republican |
|
Tarver |
85 |
Republican |
|
Wiley |
85 |
Republican |
|
Braud |
80 |
Republican |
|
Cox |
80 |
Republican |
|
Schlegel |
80 |
Republican |
|
Freiberg |
75 |
Republican |
|
Zeringue |
75 |
Republican |
|
Stagni |
71 |
Republican |
|
Adams |
70 |
Democrat |
|
Carter,
R |
70 |
Democrat |
|
Geymann |
70 |
Republican |
|
Bayham |
67 |
Republican |
|
DeVillier |
65 |
Republican |
|
Glorioso |
65 |
Republican |
|
Hilferty |
60 |
Republican |
|
Thompson |
60 |
Republican |
|
LaCombe |
55 |
Republican |
|
Martinez |
55 |
Democrat |
|
Bagley |
25 |
Republican |
|
Bryant |
25 |
Democrat |
|
Fisher |
25 |
Democrat |
|
Johnson,
T |
25 |
Democrat |
|
Brass |
15 |
Democrat |
|
Jackson |
15 |
Democrat |
|
Taylor |
15 |
Democrat |
|
Carter,
W |
10 |
Democrat |
|
Freeman |
10 |
Democrat |
|
Landry,
M |
10 |
Democrat |
|
Lyons |
10 |
Democrat |
|
Miller,
D |
10 |
Democrat |
|
Moore |
10 |
Democrat |
|
Carpenter |
5 |
Democrat |
|
Chassion |
5 |
Democrat |
|
Landry,
T |
5 |
Democrat |
|
Boyd |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Green |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Henry,
D |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Jordan |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Knox |
0 |
Democrat |
|
LaFleur |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Lavardain |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Marcelle |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Mena |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Murray |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Newell |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Phelps |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Walters |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Young |
0 |
Democrat |
In contrast to recent
years, there was greater disruption of the near-perfect partisan sorting. For
Democrats, three crested above the halfway mark, representing the only three
still from majority-white non-urban districts. However, among the lower-scoring
Republicans, Bayham, DeVillier, and especially Bagley had lower scores because they
missed a number of votes without asking for leave (DeVillier as speaker likely had
other business), and as 13 of the 14 bills were for conservative/reform measures,
an unexcused absent vote counted against. Thus, on the GOP side the relaxing of
partisan sorting might appear somewhat exaggerated. Still, Bagley aside, this
would mean no Republican scored below 55, and only two Democrats scored above
that.
In fact, it could be argued that had those three not missed votes and voted with virtually all of their colleagues on those, the House GOP could have crested its record high in 2022 of 90.84 and nearly matched last year, since the Log started to keep scores in 2004. For their parts, Democrats did set a new low despite their three 50+ scorers. As it was, the 88.42 of the GOP and 12.19 of the Democrats set a new partisan gap record of 76.23. Sorting may have become a little more imperfect, but in aggregate the two parties are farther apart than ever.
A propensity for senators to take leave that accounted for most absences during votes made for even more extremes:
|
Bass |
100 |
Republican |
|
Cloud |
100 |
Republican |
|
Miguez |
100 |
Republican |
|
Talbot |
100 |
Republican |
|
Allain |
95 |
Republican |
|
Cathey |
95 |
Republican |
|
Fesi |
95 |
Republican |
|
Henry |
95 |
Republican |
|
Hodges |
95 |
Republican |
|
Kleinpeter
|
95 |
Republican |
|
Miller,
G |
95 |
Republican |
|
Morris |
95 |
Republican |
|
Wheat |
95 |
Republican |
|
Womack |
95 |
Republican |
|
Pressly |
95 |
Republican |
|
Foil |
94 |
Republican |
|
Mizell |
94 |
Republican |
|
McMath |
94 |
Republican |
|
Myers |
94 |
Republican |
|
Abraham |
90 |
Republican |
|
Lambert |
90 |
Republican |
|
Seabaugh |
90 |
Republican |
|
Reese |
88 |
Republican |
|
Edmonds |
85 |
Republican |
|
Hensgens |
85 |
Republican |
|
Owen,
R |
85 |
Republican |
|
Stine |
85 |
Republican |
|
Connick |
83 |
Republican |
|
Jackson-Andrews |
25 |
Democrat |
|
Barrow |
5 |
Democrat |
|
Harris |
5 |
Democrat |
|
Barthelemy |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Boudreaux,
G |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Carter,
G. |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Duplessis |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Jenkins |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Luneau |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Price |
0 |
Democrat |
|
Selders |
0 |
Democrat |
The Senate GOP average was only third highest of all time, but notably the party’s lowest score was 83. Democrats’ mean score, with only three not scoring perfectly liberal/populist and just one in double digits at 25, was the lowest historically. This incredibly pure partisan sorting, with a GOP average of 92.98 and Democrat average of 3.21 and the gap from the lowest of the former to the highest of the latter of 58 led to the all-time highest partisan gap of 89.77.
Viewing the entire legislature, the GOP average came in just under 90 while Democrats’ was just above 10. Given the separate chambers’ historical rankings, not surprisingly the Republicans had their third highest historically with Democrats having obviously their lowest and almost as obviously the partisan gap was the highest ever. The Senate, despite the extreme sorting, opened up its slight conservatism/reform lead over the House a small amount, a lead it repeated after being the reverse for the previous 9 of 11 years.
Finally, GOP Gov. Jeff Landry stayed around the same place, scoring 95. The Log signs off, barring significant special session, until next spring in an election year.
No comments:
Post a Comment